Miguel Guhlin linked to this 2019 article today. It’s the most clearly written on the debate between phonics and alternative methods of learning to read that I’ve seen. Phonics is contrasted with ‘three cuing’, proposed in 1967 by education professor Ken Goodman, where students are focused on what the word means, not what it sounds like. My take on reading this is that phonics really works when we already know the spoken language or are in a situation where we can practice it a lot. We already know the meaning, so associating a word with a sound is a quick route to comprehension. When learning a second language, however, we don’t have this advantage, and we don’t want to spend five or six years fully immersed in the spoken language before learning to read it. So there is much more emphasis on meaning. And no matter how you learn, to have advanced comprehension you’re going to need much more than phonics.
Web: [Direct Link] [This Post]
Recent Stories
Autonomous cars, drones cheerfully obey prompt injection by road sign
: AI vision systems can be very literal readers
Jan 31, 2026NVIDIA is still planning to make a ‘huge’ investment in OpenAI, CEO says
Bloomberg reports that CEO Jensen Huang said NVIDIA's investment in OpenAI could be the largest the company has ever made.
Jan 31, 2026AI Agent Engineer at CollectWise
About Us CollectWise is a fast growing and well funded Y Combinator-backed startup. We’re using generative AI to automate debt collection, a $35B market in the US alone. Our AI agents are already outperforming human collectors by 2X, and we’re doing so at a fraction of the cost. With a team of three, we scaled to a $1 million annualized run rate in just a few months, and we are now hiring an AI Agent Engineer to help us reach $10 million within the next year. Role We are hiring an AI Agent Engineer to design, optimize, and productionize the...