×
AI regulation ban secretly added to GOP spending bill
Written by
Published on
Join our daily newsletter for breaking news, product launches and deals, research breakdowns, and other industry-leading AI coverage
Join Now

A controversial provision added to the House Budget Reconciliation bill would halt all state and local AI regulation for a decade, creating a regulatory vacuum at a time when governments are actively developing oversight frameworks. The sweeping preemption clause, introduced by Rep. Brett Guthrie (R-KY), would nullify both existing protections and future state-level guardrails across a broad spectrum of AI applications, potentially undermining public safety while centralizing regulatory authority at the federal level.

The big picture: House Republicans have inserted language into a budget bill that would prevent all state and local governments from regulating AI systems for 10 years.

  • The provision, introduced by Representative Brett Guthrie of Kentucky, broadly defines AI to include both newer generative models and older automated decision systems.
  • The ban would block states from enforcing both current laws and any future regulation related to artificial intelligence through 2035.

Existing protections at risk: Several state laws designed to safeguard citizens from AI harms would become unenforceable.

  • California’s requirement that healthcare providers disclose AI use in patient communications would be nullified.
  • New York’s 2021 law mandating bias audits for AI hiring tools would also be affected.
  • California’s transparency law requiring AI developers to document training data, set to take effect in 2026, would be halted.

Why this matters: The provision could create a regulatory vacuum for AI oversight at a time when governments are actively developing frameworks to protect consumers.

  • States would lose control over how they allocate federal funding for AI programs, potentially limiting innovation in responsible AI deployment.
  • The move appears designed to prevent a patchwork of state regulations, but critics argue it eliminates necessary consumer protections.

What they’re saying: Democrats and tech safety organizations have voiced strong opposition to the proposal.

  • Rep. Jan Schakowsky (D-Ill.), ranking member on the Commerce, Manufacturing and Trade Subcommittee, called it a “giant gift to Big Tech.”
  • Nonprofit groups including the Tech Oversight Project and Consumer Reports warned the provision would leave consumers unprotected from AI harms like deepfakes and algorithmic bias.

What’s next: The House Committee on Energy and Commerce, chaired by Guthrie, scheduled consideration of the text during the budget reconciliation markup on May 13.

  • The AI provision appears as an addition to broader healthcare changes in the reconciliation bill, potentially limiting dedicated debate on its technology policy implications.
GOP sneaks decade-long AI regulation ban into spending bill

Recent News

Study reveals 4 ways AI is transforming sexual wellness

AI-powered tools offer relationship advice rated more empathetic than human responses.

In the Money: Google tests interactive finance charts in AI Mode for stock comparisons

Finance queries serve as Google's testing ground for broader data visualization across other subjects.

30 mathematicians met in secret to stump OpenAI. They (mostly) failed.

Mathematicians may soon shift from solving problems to collaborating with AI reasoning bots.